5 March 2026
In secured lending, priority is paramount. Priority positioning becomes critical where there are competing secured creditors over the same asset; thereby, enticing lender to apply the relevant strategy of “tacking”.
What is tacking?
The legal principle of “tacking” permits a lender to make further advances under existing security while maintaining the same priority position. The further advances by this lender that ‘tack’ to the existing securities are known as tacking. Although conceptually straightforward, uncertainty arises on the type of property (real or personal) and whether it is governed by the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (PPSA).
The most conventional example of tacking can be illustrated as:
- A first legal mortgage is granted to Lender A, followed by a second (equitable / legal) mortgage in favour of Lender B.
- Lender A subsequently advances further funds under its existing mortgage.
The question becomes whether those additional funds retain priority over Lender B’s interest. The answer lies within the applicable legal framework, which will be discussed below.
Real Property Mortgages: The Rule Against Tacking
In the context of real property, the traditional equitable rule against tacking continues to apply as established in Hopkinson v Rolt (1861).[1] Providing that a first mortgagee cannot obtain priority for further advances made after it has actual notice of a subsequent mortgage.[2] The notice must be actual, not merely constructive. Once actual notice is received, any further advance made by the first mortgagee will rank behind the second mortgagee. This is to promote fairness among competing mortgagees as it would generally be considered unfair for an earlier lender to “tack on” the security given to the later lender after knowledge of a later security.
Limited Exceptions
The courts have recognised narrow exceptions, particularly where:
- further advances are applied to improve the mortgaged property, and
- the improvements increase the value of the property such that subsequent mortgagees are not prejudiced.
The leading case of Matzner v Clyde Securities Ltd [1975] applies the limited exceptions to the rule against tacking.[3] The first lender (Clyde), despite being given notice of second and third lenders, was tacking on advances for the purpose of increasing the value of the property. The court made clear that the further advances were in fact classified as ‘expenses incurred’ to perfect its security. Therefore, as the expenses were for aiding the enhancement of value in the property, the first lender maintained his priority and the equitable stance on tacking did not apply.
Accordingly, in real property transactions, a first mortgagee who receives notice of a second mortgage should assume that further discretionary advances will not enjoy priority unless protective steps (such as a deed of priority) are in place.
Future Advances under s 18 PPSA
Although “tacking” is not directly referenced in the PPSA, s18 encapsulates tacking by stating that a security interest may secure present and future obligations, including future advances.[4] Where the security agreement considers future advances, the perfected Interest extends to those advances.
Competing priority is determined under Part 2.6 of the PPSA, specifically:
- the order of perfection (s 55), and
- special priority rules (ss 56–60).
Notably, the PPSA does not replicate the equitable rule in Hopkinson v Rolt.[5] A secured party may retain priority for future advances even if it has knowledge of another security interest, provided it remains perfected and no special priority rule applies.[6]
Key PPSA Exceptions
In accordance with the PPSA, priority may be altered by statutory mechanisms:
- Purchase Money Security Interests (PMSIs) – s 62 PPSA.
A properly perfected PMSI receives “super priority” over earlier security interests, provided strict timing requirements are met.[7] Failure to comply will result in loss of that super priority status.
- Transitional Security Interests – s 323 PPSA.
Priority disputes involving transitional security interests are governed by specific transitional provisions.[8]
Practical Considerations for Lenders
In moving forward, lenders should be aware of the following key issues:
- despite notice, tacking is permitted in relation to the PPSA, with certain exceptions; and
- the rule against tacking applies to real property security unless it falls under common law exemptions.
In order to ensure that lenders are protecting their interests and security, precautions should be taken at the drafting stage of loan agreements to agree on acceptable priority arrangements.
For further information in relation to this or assistance in protecting your security interest, please feel free to contact Greg Conomos, Banking and Finance Managing Director, gregc@marknathan.com.au or Mary Vouros, maryv@marknathan.com.au
[1] Hopkinson v Rolt (1861) 11 ER 829 (‘Hopkinson v Rolt’).
[2] Ibid
[3] Matzner v Clyde Securities Ltd [1975] 2 NSWLR 293.
[4] Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) s 18.
[5] Hopkinson v Rolt (1861) 11 ER 829 (‘Hopkinson v Rolt’).
[6] Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) s 55-60.
[7] Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) s 62.
[8] Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) s 323.